Daniella Ferrero’s feet are firmly planted in Flagstaff, Arizona, in 2026. But for the last year, much of her mind has lived in Trelawny, Jamaica, in the 1820s.
Ferrero, a history major and an Honors College student, recently finished transcribing more than 100 pages of the writings of John Shipman, an English Methodist missionary sent to Jamaica to convert enslaved people working on sugar plantations. Her work alongside assistant teaching professor Kyle Welty—who started transcribing Shipman’s writings nearly 20 years ago at Southern Methodist University—was powered by the Honors Undergraduate Fellowship program, which provides paid research opportunities to students in the college.
“My grad school research sat and languished for a long time, but thanks to the Honors Undergraduate Fellowship program, it’s slowly coming back to life,” Welty said.
The transcribing project didn’t just prepare Ferrero for a career in archival work—she hopes to pursue research in Latin American colonial history, especially the independence movements there—but it also added new dimension to an oft-misunderstood time and place.
“This has opened my eyes a lot to the importance of archives and all the work that goes into creating one,” Ferrero said. “Archives need to survive and stay accessible to communities, otherwise the details and nuance of history can get lost.”
Setting the scene
In early 19th-century Jamaica, Welty said, everything revolved around the institution of slavery. Enslaved people working on plantations made up nearly 90% of the island’s population. Almost everyone who wasn’t enslaved was involved in slavery in some way—whether they owned plantations, worked on them as paid overseers or profited off slavery as merchants.
“The missionaries were in a weird third category,” Welty said. “They weren’t technically there to support slavery; they were there to spread the gospel and convert people to the Methodist faith. As evangelists, they were pro-education. That put planters in an uneasy mood. They thought, ‘If they’re taught about the liberation of the Israelites from Egypt, will that put ideas into their heads?’”
Ferrero explained that missionaries in the Caribbean had to walk a fine line between staying palatable to the “master class” of white plantation owners and staying true to their England-based faith, whose leaders had just begun to take an anti-slavery stance.
“There was a big abolitionist movement starting in the Methodist Church in England,” Ferrero said. “But John Shipman was living in a society built on slavery, so he couldn’t be seen threatening the institution of slavery. He knew the planters could ask him to leave at any time.”
Ferrero transcribed a letter Shipman wrote to planters to put their minds at ease. He assured them he wasn’t there to threaten slavery, even going so far as to make unpalatable remarks about the differences between enslaved people and the ruling class.
“It ended up getting him recalled” from Jamaica and sent back to England, Welty said. “He called out the irony of that in another letter: ‘You want us to work in a slave-dominant culture, but you’re abolitionists? You can’t have it both ways.’”
It’s complicated
Based on Shipman’s letter to the planter class, some might assume the missionary was pro-slavery. But Shipman, like any human in any time period, was full of contradictions. While transcribing, Ferrero was fascinated to find a crossed-out passage in Shipman’s book draft that seemed to indicate a burgeoning abolitionist stance.
“He said something like, ‘If enslaved people on a plantation are being called to do immoral things that go against the teachings of the Bible, they should leave,’” Ferrero said. “He crossed that out, because he knew that if he ever wanted to get this book published, a thought like that could never have seen the light of day.”
Ferrero noticed plenty of contradictory language throughout the long document.
“He’ll say something like, ‘The enslaved people have the capacity to be and do more; things might be different for them if they weren’t deprived of opportunities,’” Ferrero said. “But even as he writes this, he repeats racial stereotypes from that time.”
Welty and Ferrero’s work points to a timeless lesson that’s important to remember: History is rarely straightforward because people are not one-dimensional.
“The common perspective today is that these missionaries were an arm of the colonial agenda,” Welty said. “That’s true, but it’s more complicated than that. They were there with a variety of intentions and motives, sometimes in outright opposition of the planter class. It shows a more complicated status on the ground. I think if we can appreciate that—if we can see nuance in historical figures—we can extend that to our contemporaries.”

Jill Kimball | NAU Communications
(928) 523-2282 | jill.kimball@nau.edu
